Data limitation — recent publication years are incomplete in the 2016 file.
The file is a 2016 snapshot, so it holds only the books catalogued by then. Records per publication year peak at 216,695 (2009) and are still 215,952 (2010) and 205,001 (2011),
then fall to 191,867 (2012), 159,590 (2013), 129,045 (2014), 75,905 (2015) and 22,518 (2016); 903 records are dated 2017–2020. The pattern fits cataloguing lag (books published shortly before the snapshot not yet catalogued) rather than a fall in publishing; I have not checked it against outside publication counts. Nothing here has been removed or corrected.
It affects the results: every 2020 total, sigmoid fit and inflection year is computed with these incomplete years.
Refitting on 1400–2011 moves the inflection years earlier by a median of 1.3 years (3.2 years for a 2008 cutoff), so absolute inflection years depend on the cutoff.
The Jeffersonian vs non-Jeffersonian comparison keeps its direction and significance: gap +2.2 years (Mann-Whitney p=0.0025) with the 2011 cutoff, +2.4 years (p=0.0015) with 2008, against +1.6 years (p=0.0039) using all years;
median growth 211× (Jeffersonian) vs 414× (non-Jeffersonian) with the 2011 cutoff. Details: output/sensitivity_cutoff_report.txt.
Library of Congress Classification — Cumulative Record Counts · 1400–2020
Library of Congress Classification analysis · auto-loaded dashboard — LC MARC 2016 files (10,543,015 records; 9,500,598 with a valid LC class and year 1400–2020; 9,500,598 in the 238 analysed subclasses = every valid LC subclass). Non-LCC call numbers (MLC, MIC, CPB, LAW …) are excluded.
Reading: Each line = one of 21 main LCC classes. Rank 1 = most cumulative records at that snapshot.
Colors distinguish classes. Solid = no dash convention (most are solid). Use the legend below to highlight key stories.
Class rank trajectories — 21 LCC classes · 1480–2020 · rank 1 = most records
Legend:· click to toggle
Rebuttal: H (Social Sciences) rose from rank 10 in 1815 to
rank 2 by 1970. K (Law — Jefferson's dominant class) went from
rank 1 to rank 5 by 2020.
Post-LCC era (1897–1970): H grew 20×; K grew 4.6×. (Class totals include every valid LC subclass; E and F now counted.)
H vs K — class rank in LC collection · 1815–2020
Reading:Solid blue = H class ·
Solid red = K class ·
Solid lines = Jefferson-catalogued (MERGED). Dashed = absent from Jefferson (ABSENT).
Rank 1 = most records among all 25 H+K subclasses combined.
H & K subclass rank trajectories — 25 subclasses · 1815–2020
Reading: Solid lines = Jefferson-classified (MERGED/DIRECT). Dashed = absent from Jefferson (ABSENT).
Vertical markers: red = 1897 LCC created · blue = 1968 MARC era begins.
Both groups inflect in the same era — driven by MARC cataloging and university expansion, not Jefferson.
Filter class:Y-axis:
🔍 Search lines:
Cumulative record counts by subclass
Jefferson-classified (MERGED)
Absent from Jefferson (ABSENT)
Reading: Each line = one LCC subclass (238 total). Rank 1 = most cumulative records at that snapshot.
Solid blue = MERGED (Jefferson-classified) ·
Solid green = DIRECT (Jefferson direct) ·
Dashed orange = ABSENT (non-Jefferson) ·
Dotted gold = RENAMED (Jefferson direct) ·
Filter by main class or Jefferson status. Click legend items to highlight individual subclasses.
Class:Status:Top N:
🔍 Search lines:
Subclass rank trajectories — 1480–2020
Legend:· click any item to toggle · highlighted = shown
Reading: Solid = Jefferson-classified (MERGED). Dashed = absent from Jefferson (ABSENT).
Short vertical ticks at bottom = sigmoid inflection year. If hierarchy persisted, solid lines should inflect earlier.
Gap of — years between groups. Both inflected in the same era driven by MARC cataloging and university expansion, not Jefferson.
P class — Western vs Non-Western Literatures
H class — Classic vs Modern Social Sciences
Inflection years: Each dot = one LCC subclass. Top row = Jeffersonian (MERGED/DIRECT). Bottom row = Non-Jeffersonian (ABSENT). Bubble size = record count.
Dashed vertical lines show group means (from inflection_comparison.csv if loaded, otherwise computed from scatter data).
Python analysis (normalized sigmoid): Non-Jeffersonian mean = 1986, Jeffersonian mean = 1984, gap = 1.6 years — trivially small (0.8% of 200-year study period).
Filter by class:load rankings CSV for data
Sigmoid inflection year t₀ — Jeffersonian vs Non-Jeffersonian subclasses
Jeffersonian (MERGED/DIRECT)
Non-Jeffersonian (ABSENT)
Methodological note: The previous scatter assigned chapter counts at the class level, making correlation a weak tool across groups. The right question is a two-group test: do Jeffersonian and non-Jeffersonian subclasses differ in their long-run growth? Welch's t-test on log10(growth) answers this directly. Violin = density; white line = median; diamond = mean; box = IQR; whiskers = 1.5xIQR. Each dot = one subclass.
Long-run growth distribution — density + subclass dots · hover for details
median
◆ mean
box=IQR
whiskers=1.5xIQR
Sigmoid inflection year distribution — density + subclass dots · hover for details
Jeffersonian (MERGED/DIRECT/RENAMED)
Non-Jeffersonian (ABSENT)
Inflection year t0 comes from fitted sigmoid models in subclass_sigmoids_v2.csv. Density curves show KDE of inflection timing. Dots below each group's axis show individual subclasses.
REBUTTAL TO: "THE POST-JEFFERSON LCC SYSTEM ENTRENCHED ELITE KNOWLEDGE HIERARCHIES"
Finding: In the post-LCC formation era (1897–1970), the three fastest-growing classes were
H Social Sciences, L Education, and T Technology
— all domains a suppression theory would predict to lag. Law (K) and Language & Lit (P) both grew more slowly.
Bars sorted by post-LCC growth. Red = Jeffersonian/elite classes. Green = other classes.
Growth factor = (records at end of era) / (records at start of era) · computed from cumulative CSV
Growth factor by LCC main class — three eras · sorted by post-LCC formation growth
Pre-LCC (1815–1897)
Post-LCC formation (1897–1970)
Modern era (1970–2020)
Jeffersonian/elite class
REBUTTAL TO: "JEFFERSON'S CLASSIFICATION SUPPRESSED DEMOCRATIC/SOCIAL KNOWLEDGE DOMAINS"
Finding: The share of "democratic" classes
(H Social Sciences, E American History, F Local History, J Political Science, G Geography) in total LC holdings
doubled from ~11% (1815) to ~23% (2020), while Jefferson-heavy classes (K Law, P Language & Lit, B Philosophy)
fell from ~46% to ~37%.
Implication: If the classification system encoded a hierarchy that privileged Jeffersonian elite knowledge,
it failed completely. Over two centuries the system amplified, not suppressed, democratic subject domains.
H+E+F+J+G = Social Sciences, American History, Local History, Political Science, Geography · K+P+B = Law, Language & Lit, Philosophy
Share of total LC holdings — "democratic" vs Jeffersonian-heavy classes · 1815–2020
Democratic classes — all subclasses (H+E+F+J+G)
Democratic classes — Jefferson subclasses only
Jeffersonian-heavy — all subclasses (K+P+B)
Jeffersonian-heavy — Jefferson subclasses only
Mean inflection year — Non-Jeffersonian vs Jeffersonian subclasses